The rambling thoughts of a Modern Orthodox Chassid (whatever that means). Contact me at emansouth @

Thursday, March 01, 2007

More Shuffle Stuff

Intrigued by the imbalance I experienced listening to the first 20 songs on my iPod shuffle, I decided to listen to a lot more. After listening to over 150 of my 895 songs, I can report, without hesitation, that the shuffle feature is, indeed, random, as advertised.

While seemingly unusual patterns emerge from time to time, listening to enough songs makes it clear that the "patterns" are random.

One other advantage that came from shuffling: There are a number of albums on my CD that I have no patience for. I could never sit through an entire Adi Ran or Sinai Tor album, for example. But I found myself much more able to deal with their weird stuff on a song by song basis. I even liked some of it (and admired much of it for it's freshness (weird though it may be).

Which brings me to a legal point (I'm sure you see the connection).

The Federal Trade Commission will have to rule on whether the proposed merger of Sirious and XM satellite radio firms would violate anti-trust law. I have seen some discussion about how to define the "market". Is it the market for satellite radio or all radio?

I have another thought. I think the market should also include iPods. Why would you pay $15 a month for satellite radio when you can just shuffle your iPod? I think iPods are the real competition.

(BTW, that's my expert legal opinion coming from a lawyer who knows zilch about anti-trust law. Ignorance has never stopped me from offering opinions before).



  • At 2:59 PM, Blogger Isaac Zucker said…

    It is not your ignorance regarding anti-trust law that is disturbing, it is your ignorance of the difference between an iPod and sattellite radio that I find troubling. Last time I checked my iPod couldn't play (i) the home and away broadcasts of every NFL team for all games, (ii) every baseball game, (iii) NASCAR race coverage, (iv) the Fox News Channel, (v) Court TV, etc. Sattelite radio is much more than commercial free music. Including terrestrial radio in the same market is, I believe, a stretch; including iPods in the same market is absurd.

    The NASCAR reference is included just in case anyone down south reads this. Can't those guys make a right turn once in a while?

  • At 6:01 PM, Blogger MoChassid said…

    Where can I go to sign up? Now that I know that they have CAR RACES on RADIO I'm really pumped!

  • At 12:03 AM, Blogger Just Passing Through said…

    check it out. It talks bout the shuffle: random or not?,239029154,339274094,00.htm


Post a Comment

<< Home